One more point may be added, namely that the deductive approach allows the teacher to deal with immediate grammar issues on the go, rather than having to anticipate and prepare for them in advance thornbury 1999. The inductive grammar lesson lets the students get input experience regarding the grammatical structure first through a topic or theme of interest. Deductive approach vs inductive approach in teaching duration. Effectiveness of inductive and deductive methods in. Inductive and deductive approach of teaching grammar. The controversy over approaches of teaching grammar has developed in the recent past, but the question remains as to the relative effectiveness of different approaches. Each of them carries both strengths and weaknesses thornbury, 1999. The effect of deductive and inductive learning strategies. It is a more student centered approach to learning.
Inductive teaching sometimes known as inquiry or discovery teaching involves giving the students examples of language and working with them to come up with grammatical rules. This procedure has been derived from my great interest in innovative grammar teaching and my teaching experience in grammar. Inductive and deductive approaches to teaching english grammar. Teaching and learning of grammar at the basic level of. First, consider the approach to deal with any grammatical structure. Therefore, in this study, the effectiveness of inductive and deductive approaches in teaching grammar to adult learners of english is studied. In fact, many teachers prefer a deductive lesson because they believe it saves time and helps students focus on what they need to be focused on. The study investigates the comparative effectiveness of teaching english grammar by using deductive and inductive teaching models. One way of grammar is that examples are given to the students. More comprehensively, ellis1 2006 defines grammar teaching as. Example of deductive grammar approach walker and elsworth,1986 walker and elsworth. Some possible activities in deductive approach are. A deductive approach starts with the presentation of a rule and is followed by examples in which the rule is applied. In the early 20th century, a behaviorist perspective to language learning emerged that viewed language as a stimulusresponse sr chain.
Teaching grammar using the deductive approach a good example of deductive teaching is seen in the fields of science and engineering, whereby the instructor introduces the subject matter by lecturing on general principles, then gives students practice in their applications for homework prince et al, 2006. Jon hird, materials writer and teacher trainer, discusses inductive and deductive grammar teaching, comparing and contrasting the two, and debating the pros and cons of their use in the classroom there are two main ways that we tend to teach grammar. Lets take a closer look at the differences between inductive and deductive instruction, and find out how noticing can be used in the language classroom to better facilitate student learning. In a study done by ediger 1983, numerous issues are discussed pertaining to the elementary school curriculum, including selection of learning activities, the structure of knowledge, teaching of grammar. It could be said that the already mentioned concepts activate different. Fortyseven secondsemester french students were taught eight grammatical structures. Foreign language methodologists and teachers have long debated whether deductive or inductive teaching yields better outcomes for second language acquisition. The grammar rule is presented and the learner engages with it through the study and manipulation of examples. Teaching grammar using deductive and inductive approaches. Therefore, when using language productively in speaking or writing, we need explicit presentation of grammar rules. The deductive approach is faster and can be an efficient way to teach large numbers of facts and concrete concepts. A deductive approach is based on the topdown theory which the presentation and explanation of grammar rules take the presedence over teaching. The necessity of grammar teaching fengjuan wang engineering and commerce college of southcentral university for nationalities hongshan district, wuhan, hubei province430065, china email. Implications of an inductive versus deductive approach to sla grammar instruction by emily kuder.
Subsequently, the investigation seeks to decipher moroccan university. Inductive, deductive, integrated and lecture method of. With this approach, the teachers role is to provide meaningful contexts to encourage demonstration of the rule, while the students evolve the rules from the examples of its use and continued practice. The aim of this paper was to try to provide some insights as to whether the inductive or deductive method of instruction is more effective in the context of teaching english as a foreign language to primary learners. Teaching grammar in context david nunan metaphors for second language acquisition from a grammatical perspective, many foreign language programmes and teaching materials are based on a linear model of language acquisition. The inductive approach and deductive approach in tesol are two common methods for teaching english grammar. Examining the effectiveness references of adopting an. Surely,this is unapplicable for multilingual classes. A deductive approach deductive teaching is a traditional approach in which information about target.
The student works out the rules of the grammar point. In a valid deductive argument, all of the content of the conclusion is present, at least implicitly, in the premises. The vast range of approaches and methods from grammar translation and audiolingualism over communicative language teaching clt to input hypothesis krashen, 1997, cited in cook, 2008, p. Early theories on grammar instruction supported the grammartranslation approach which concentrated on grammar skills and was commonly used to teach latin and greek terrell, 1991. Difference between inductive and deductive language. While there is a consensus on how to apply the deductive method, the inductive approach has been implemented in several ways. Both deductive and inductive teaching have their pros and cons and which. Deductive method of teaching deductive teaching is a more traditional form of teaching.
This paper is aimed at investigating students attitudes towards inductive and deductive approaches to teaching grammar of english as a foreign language. This study set out to examine whether or not these two types of teaching would differently affect. These are deductive approach and inductive approach. In traditional setting, grammar teaching is seen as the presentation and practice of discrete grammatical structures. There are benefits to both approaches, though they are quite different. This model operates on the premise that learners acquire one target language item at a time, in a sequential, stepbystep. Some students that prefer the formal and more lineal style of teaching grammar could feel shocked or simply isolated.
It is a teachercentred approach to presenting new content. This present study investigated whether pupils who were taught grammar through the inductive approach would do better than those taught through the deductive approach. In a deductive classroom, the teacher conducts lessons by introducing and explaining concepts to students, and then expecting students to complete tasks to practice the concepts. This is compared with an inductive approach, which starts with examples and asks learners to find rules, and hence is more learnercentred. The effectiveness of modified inductive versus deductive. Pdf teaching and learning of grammar at the basic level. Deductive and inductive strategies for language acquisition 5 example, explicit teaching can raise awareness of nonsalient features in the target language, prompting the learner to induce their own set of grammar rules and effectively priming them for the acquisition of implicit knowledge r.
In the tefl classroom, inductive and deductive teaching methods are two different approaches used in teaching grammar. In the western world, deductive teaching approaches are common in classrooms where english is the first language. Then, after being exposed to the structure about seven to ten times, the students natural thinking processes see. The purpose of this study is to reveal the grammar teaching approaches that are used at the moroccan university efl classrooms. Inductive reasoning is openended and exploratory especially at the beginning. Inductive approach in grammar teaching a deductive and an inductive approach basically differentiate in lesson procedures, learner roles, teacher roles and usage of metalanguage in the teaching process. Inductive and deductive approch in teaching grammar. Pdf deductive and inductive grammar teaching arnis. Brown concludes, while it might be appropriate at times to articulate a rule and then proceed to instances, most of the evidence in communicative second language teaching points to the superiority of an inductive approach to rules and generalizations. The effect of deductive approach and inductive approach on. On the other hand, deductive reasoning is narrow in nature and is concerned with testing or confirming hypothesis.
A deductive approach to teaching language starts by giving learners rules, then examples, then practice. Furthermore, the perceptions of lecturers and learners about these two ways of grammar teaching are investigated. Deductive approach vs inductive approach in teaching. In a deductive lesson, the teacher can give the students the grammar rule of present perfect and let them explain the rule to each other. According to brown 3 and thornbury 12, both inductive approach and deductive approach have their strengths. H amidovic 191 prefer the traditional or deductive approach, primarily focusing on form, or the inductive approach, primarily based on a specific language function in correlation with a specific context and mean.
Deductive and inductive approaches are opposing each other. The deductive method is traditional, structured, and predictable, while the inductive method is personalized, and the concepts are easily remembered and understood. Literature on approaches to teaching grammar favours the inductive approach as a better strategy for building students grammatical and communicative skills. Conversely, inductive instruction is a much more studentcentred approach and makes use of a strategy known as noticing. Pdf inductive and deductive methods of teaching andrie.
Therefore the learners are told the grammatical rule and will work from that. In deductive approach the rule is firstly verbalized by the teacher and then the learners apply it. Inductive and deductive instruction university of alberta. The current study will explore the deductive and inductive approaches to explicit grammar instruction in comparison to one another. Deductive approach teachingenglish british council bbc. Deductive instruction of grammar to efl students x 1 5. This study investigates the effectiveness of deductive and guided inductive approaches for teaching grammar in college french classrooms. Introduction deductive and inductive grammar teaching are both methods used by many teacher s to introduce grammar rules, or to send students on a search of a rule, both concepts are extremely different. Literature on approaches to teaching grammar favours the inductive approach as a better strategy for building students grammatical and communicative skills than the deductive approach. Mean score of pretest mean score of posttest number of learners accrual % deductive group 34,607 46,1 95 11,524 inductive group 36,425 45,664 95 9,239 ential skill in language teaching. The deductive method is a method of verification where information comes from a specific source and is delivered to students directly, while the inductive method is an approach.
1539 1184 1276 139 709 238 755 493 1305 300 585 1228 392 544 279 994 224 122 312 946 744 44 1110 369 254 1184 1145 33 413 67 511 931 1106 222 596 1380